The whole story, as text
9.9% with a 6% fee, or 12.5% with no fee?
9.9% with a 6% fee, or 12.5% with no fee? Both put $8,000 in your hand, repaid over 48 months. The fee comes out of the loan before you get the money. How many dollars is the 6% fee?
The answer
$511. Not $480. The fee is charged on what you borrow, and you have to borrow $8,510.64 to walk away with $8,000.
Why
A fee taken out of the loan means you borrow more than you receive, and pay interest on the fee too. $511 fee, $8,000 cash in hand. Every one of the 48 payments carries interest on the $511 as well. Over 48 months: 9.9% with the fee: $215 a month, cost $2,341. 12.5% with no fee: $213 a month, cost $2,207.
One move
Compare the cost of borrowing, not the rate. 9.9% + 6% fee: $215 a month, $2,341 cost of borrowing. 12.5%, no fee: $213 a month, $2,207 cost of borrowing. The 12.5% loan costs $135 less over the term. Estimated APR 13.21% with the fee, 12.5% without. The lender's disclosure is the authoritative figure.
The comparison is on equal cash in hand: each offer is sized so you receive exactly $8,000. That is the only fair way to compare a loan with a deducted fee against one without.
Yours
Which offer really costs less? runs these numbers for any loan. Nothing you enter leaves your browser.
Written and reviewed by Riverbend Crossroads Digital LLC, Friday, October 2, 2026. Figures from the Show Real Cost engine, computed exactly and shown to the cent. Educational, not advice; your lender's disclosures are the authoritative figures. How we calculate · Corrections.